
The
last time Acer set foot into the SatNav world we had to eat our hats
as they produced a quite reputable PDA the N35 which more than did
the job, now they are taking on the all in one GPS market with the
latest Acer D100 SatNav system. At first when we got our unit for
review we thought someone had sent us a TomTom Go by mistake, the
same bulbous shape can hardly be a mistake, but as soon as you see
the control on the front it's clear the D100 is different.Built
around Windows CE .net 4.2 the 266Mhz ARM processor manages to power
the unit sufficiently and a mixture of 64mb Ram and 32Mb Rom provide
the space to run the software routing, all maps are stored on SD
card and the D100 ships in the UK with UK and Ireland maps on 256mb
SD card. The 300 gram device is suspiciously equipped along the same
lines as TomTom but without cracking open the package we can't
confirm this, however the big difference is that TomTom run a Linux
client and Acer have opted for Microsoft.
Acer's other major decision is to use Destinator software on the
D100, we have tested Destinator quite thoroughly in the past and so
decided to concentrate the review on Acers implementation of the
whole package. Start-up from cold left us sitting in the car park at
work for almost 1 minute and 30 seconds before we got enough
satellites using the inbuilt 12 channel receiver. Not bad we thought
but not up to the performance of the few units using the latest
SiRF® StarIII chipset, the Acer D100 relies on the older II chipset
(the same as the current TomTom go range).
The D100 is supplied with a windscreen mounting system which is
in 2 parts, the first is the sucker system and adjustable mount
plate, onto which the cradle is connected, this in turn has an 8 pin
connector which allows power to be fed to the unit. The power lead
connects to the side of the cradle which is actually quite easy to
fir the D100 into even using one hand. The whole thing seems quite
secure and didn't rattle or wobble too much during any of our
journeys.
Setting your destination soon shows that the touch screen is the
quickest entry method for text although there are other controls
including a 4 way joystick under the screen. We tested with a simple
point to point route although waypoints are supported, the route we
chose is our favourite test one that can use motorway or A roads and
leaves lot of opportunities for a wrong turn.
Soon we were on our way with the bright 3.5" screen showing our
route with a mixture of a rolling map and simple directional arrows,
the voice guidance is up to the job and seemed loud enough using the
units 2 watt speaker. The route selected was a good mix of motorway
and A roads and the D100 did an impressive job of keeping us on
course using the Destinator software. However it was time to start
taking some crazy eddies and going off piste, firstly we left the
motorway one junction early and watched as the Acer quickly
calculated the way back, although it did insist on getting us back
on the motorway. We continued away from the M25 and eventually the
D100 go the idea and plotted round the one junction left and used a
fairly obvious B road to get us to our destination.
The
Destinator software is not as intuitive as the TomTom or Garmin
interface but we did find it reliable and accurate, the usability is
really only a factor when inputting data, once on the move we found
the map view and instructions to be clear. Further detours from the
chosen route managed to extract the same behaviour with the Acer
wanting to go back to its original route for quite some time before
eventually plotting a new route from its new location.
The screen didn't suffer too much from reflections, not that we
had much sunlight to test with in January, but the backlight is
strong and the colours convincing making for a stress free drive,
even the night mode works well with a dimmer but equally readable
display. During our many test journeys we did note that occasionally
the map would stall for a few seconds (perhaps as many as 20) this
we presume is down to the extra bloat of Windows CE rather than
Destinator, its not a big issue unless you happen to be approaching
a turn in central London!
While most of us will power the Acer from the 12 volt cigarette
lighter it is worth noting that it has its own 2200 mAh battery
giving 6 hours life from a 6 hour charge. There are also a few
extras which take the form of bundled applications which can be
accessed from the main menu, there is an MP3 player and picture
viewer both of which work but we question the need for them in a
navigation product. Acer have also used the Windows CE base to build
a full contacts sync system again using active sync and the USB
host, simply hook your D100 to a PC running active sync and you can
push all your contacts to the unit. This means you can navigate to a
contact which is quite a handy feature, sadly the lack of any
Bluetooth of GSM capability means that the phone numbers are largely
redundant.
Over the course of a weeks use we came to like the Acer D100, its
more than a match for the Garmin C320 and also the older TomTom Go
classic, but even with a newer version of the Destinator software
its not real on a par with the latest TomTom Go range and is really
offering features you could get a year ago. We'd expect a new system
to have the SiRF® Star III chipset and the fact that Acer do not
have this makes us think they are merely loading Destinator on an
outgoing hardware platform.
So it all comes down to price, currently at the time of
publishing the Acer D100 is around the £200 mark which pitches it
straight at the Go 300 which is quite a challenge. Overall its a
good solid if not ground breaking device and if Acer pitch it around
£30 cheaper it would be worth strong consideration.

Published - 15/01/2006
More SatNav Reviews-
[ Up ] [ Navman iCN510 Review ] [ Garmin C320 Review ] [ Mio 268 Review ] [ Magellan Roadmate 300 ] [ TomTom Go 700 ] [ GPS Navigation System Reviews ] [ Mio 269 Review ] [ TomTom One ] [ Mio A201 Review ] [ TomTom Rider Motorbike GPS ] [ Medion GoPal 350 Review ] [ Mio C210 Review ] [ Sony Nav-U Review ] [ Garmin i2 Review ] [ TomTom One Europe Review ] [ Navman N60i Review ] [ TomTom Go 520 Review ] [ Navman N20 Review ] [ Mio GPS Review ] [ Garmin Zumo 550 Review ] [ TomTom One XL ] [ Navman F20 Review ] [ Loox N100 Review ] [ Snooper Indago Review ] [ Acer D100 Review ] [ TomTom Go 910 Review ] [ Garmin i3 Review ] [ Garmin Nuvi Review ] [ Navman iCN320 Review ] [ TomTom Go 500 ] [ TomTom Go 300 Review ] [ Acer N35 Review ] |