
The
golden rule in gadget land is that prices will fall on any
technology given time and the latest area to see some sense kicking
in the the Portable Media Player or PMP. Our review sample this week
is a prime candidate for a best buy award as the Cowon iAudio D2 PMP
makes full video replay on a portable device accessible for under
£160, where just a year ago you would have been looking north of
£250 from a brand you had never heard of.Measuring 78.0 X 55.4 X
16.6 mm and weighing just 91 grams the D2 is one of the smallest
PMP's we've seen to date and is in fact smaller than a credit card
(although not as thin). It easily sits in the palm of your hand or
neatly in a pocket in fact the only disappointment is that the
screen is 4:3 and not a full 16:9 aspect ratio.
The whole front is taken up by a 2.5" TFT screen which is a real
operational touch screen, no clickable corners or scroll wheels. The
styling is at best functional if not just a tad geek, the lack of
controls on the front does make it look very clean and crisp and
only the top edge contains a few basic buttons and sliders. Both
audio and video files are stored on flash memory of which our unit
was loaded with 4gb equivalent to an iPod Nano but you can also top
this up using the SD / MMC card slot.
The 320 by 240 pixel resolution screen looks good and presents a
very simple interface which enables you to navigate the Cowon with
consummate ease. So what do you get for your cash? The D2 is
primarily a music player that supports MP3, OGG, WMA, FLAC and WAV
which is a very comprehensive list of formats, it also handles the
AVI format which is limited to the same resolution as the screen and
will probably have to be created via the bundled Jet audio software.
We started by loading a collection of audio tracks onto the Cowon
iAudio D2 via the USB 2.0 port which was a speedy process as the
unit is recognised by both Windows and Mac as a mass storage device.
The tracks appear in a folder structure and are navigable using the
touch screen. Select a track and hit play to hear as we did, that
the Cowon really does sound good, even with the standard earbuds the
audio is punchy and yet well weighted with a clarity that you'd
normally only get from the best MP3 players.
When
tested with a set of Shure E2C's then the D2 really comes alive
managing to extract the best sound from our encoded MP3 files at
192kbps and some Ogg files encoded at the same high bitrate. As the
unit was passed around the office we did start to notice one flaw of
the touch screen design, the dreaded finger prints! It seems that
the 2.5" LCD is highly susceptible to the odd paw print and within a
few hours of visiting various desks it looked like a group of 8 year
olds had taken it to a finger painting class.
Next time to try video playback and essential part of a PMP and
the only real difference between a high end MP3 player and a PMP. We
took some WMV files which had been ripped from DVD's for previous
PMP tests and fed them into the Jet audio software running on a PC,
they were quickly processed and chopped down to size in AVI format.
Once loaded onto the D2 they played smoothly enough but the pictures
had suffered two fold, once from the compression and also from being
shoehorned into such a low resolution (QVGA). We did try pushing
over a WMV file encoded at VGA resolution just on the off chance
that it would play, of course it could be stored but trying to
playback the file crashed the D2 and required a reboot to bring it
back to life. We tried some higher resolution files (2mbits) and
pushed these through the Jet software, these produced better more
watchable video files but the increase in file size meant the
transcode took longer.
There is an FM tuner within the D2 and much to our surprise it is
quite good, normally these things just get thrown in as a last
minute thought, but not only is the tuner well integrated (you can
even record from it at 256kbits) but it also very sensitive. So we
could test not just with national radio stations like radio one and
classic FM but also some of the local stations which still sounded
good without too much hiss and fade.
The D2 can also be used as a photo viewer with JPEG supported and
the ability to build slideshows, this feature combined with a TV out
should be a winner, but unlike other PMP's the D2 cannot show song
titles or other details alongside the slideshow which we found a bit
limiting.
What
the Cowon does have going for it in a big way is the battery, Cowon
claim a 50hr music playback time for the D2 and we had a bit of a
tough time testing that and ended up leaving it running on a desk
for over 40hrs before admitting defeat. Use of the LCD screen
backlight can reduce this performance but we doubt anyone would
leave the backlight on enough to make a real dent in the huge
battery life. Video playback is more taxing and does require the
backlight, we still managed over 8 hours video replay enough for a
transatlantic flight. This excellent battery performance is down to
the flash memory which is much more energy efficient to read from
than a spinning disk as used in an iPod.
The Cowon iAudio D2 could be accused of falling between two
stalls. It is neither a fully fledged PMP due to its limitations in
the video department and it is more than an MP3 player even a video
iPod which has the same 2.5" screen size as the D2. Perhaps the
closest comparison is with the iRiver Clix which is also a mixture
of video PMP and MP3 player and has roughly the same screen size, if
we pitch these two head to head then the massive battery life of the
Cowon and the full touch screen win through.
So the Cowon D2 manages to address a niche for the ultra portable
PMP, we are just not yet convinced that there is a real market for a
small PMP, even with a big battery.

Published - 20/05/2007
More PMP Reviews -
|