
Why should Sky subscribers have al the fun?
We've been waiting for
a Freeview PVR for over a year now and the constantly delayed
Panasonic TUCTH100 Freeview PVR has
finally made it to market, this twin tuner hard disk device promises
so much but is it really a match for a Sky+ box?The rather
innocuous silver unit measures 350 x 253 x 65mm and fits in nicely
with most modern TV's and flat panels. Powering up the
TUCTH100 kicks the fans into life which seem take make more than
their fair share of noise and seem to run even when the unit is
hardly doing anything.
Our first task was to load up the EPG the Panasonic holds 7 days
worth of EPG data and the first time we set the box up it took a
good 23 minutes to download all the listings into the box. The EPG
itself isn't the best we've seen, once you've selected a channel it
only shows the listings for that service which is a bit of a pain
and its not exactly speedy in navigation taking a few seconds to
switch between listings.
That said you can use the EPG to mark up what you want to record
in a very Sky+ like fashion, however we did note that once you've
marked up a recording and powered down the box its not possible to
see what you have tagged on the EPG although you can see a list of
scheduled recordings elsewhere. You can receive over 30 TV channels
free of charge with Freeview but that will be your limit as the
Panasonic does not have the ability to take a Top Up TV card.
Recordings were of a very high quality with only slight
pixelation, we calculate you'd get around 40 hours onto the 80gb
internal hard drive and the quality isn't that far off DVD to the
untrained eye. Replay is straight forward process but still not
quite as slick as the Sky+ system, you can also time shift live TV
using one of the tuners and the unit will always be recording a 15
minute buffer unless you instruct otherwise.
The Panasonic TUCTH100 also has some simple editing features
included allowing not only to fast forward through adverts but to
actually trim them out of the recorded file altogether, this is
primarily design so you can offload the recorded files to VHS or
other outboard storage.
Our recordings did suffer from a number of software bugs, firstly
we couldn't find anyway to extend recordings, so if a programme is
running late the EPG may update to reflect this but the box will not
take this information into account meaning our test recordings of
snooker were all incomplete. Our PVR also seemed to have a habit of
freezing every so often this almost always seemed to coincide with
instructions to rewind the live programme or when performing a
number of complicated tasks.
It does look like despite the unit being some 4 months late to
market (at least) it is still with a more than its fair share of
bugs, a Panasonic dealer we were talking to said almost 70% of the
units he had sold had returned to his store within 14 days. It's a
real shame as this twin tuner Freeview unit does make 1st class
recordings and the software user interface isn't that bad, but a PVR
has to perform its primary function reliably.
There is no point in disappearing off on business expecting a
weeks worth of east enders on your unit only to find it froze
the day after you left, we really had high hopes that this would be
the first useable Freeview PVR but Panasonic need to release a new
version of software ASAP before the TUCTH100 gets a reputation it
can't recover from.
Priced at £239 you'd be a brave man to buy one just now, its
expected that a new release of software is planned for June but if
Panasonics timing can be gauged from the initial device release it
may take much longer.

Published - 24/04/2005
More Freeview Box Reviews-
[ Up ] [ Panasonic TUCTH100 Freeview PVR ] [ Slingbox Review ] [ Topfield Freeview PVR Review ] [ Humax 9200-T Freeview PVR Review ] [ Sagem 6280T PVR Review ] [ Thomson Top Up TV Plus ] [ Goodmans GHD8015F2 Review ] [ Sony Freeview PVR ] |