
It
was only a few weeks back that we had a chance to play with the
Podgear Pocket party which is probably the smallest iPod speaker
system we've tested and also the quietest! Now we get our mitts on
it's bigger brother the Podgear Houseparty which promises a bigger
sound to match it's increased size.Before we dive in it's fair to
point out that this Houseparty unit is not in the same league as the
offerings from Bose, monitor audio and Altec Lansing. Instead
it's nearest rival is the Logic3 iStation and both sit around the
£40 - £60 bracket for cheap and cheerful iPod amplification.
The Podgear Houseparty tries to offer basic amplification to the
whole range of Apple iPod's from the smallest shuffle to a full size
iPod. The main slot into which you site the player is full iPod
sized and then you use a series of plastic holders to make the
smaller models fit. Our 30gb iPod sat snugly enough and started to
both charge and sync with iTunes as it's able to connect to your PC
from the dock, but the iPod mini seemed to rattle around in it's
plastic holder which all felt a bit cheap and nasty.
With
our iPod sitting in the Podgear almost comfortably it was time to
see what it sounded like. The first track was some MOR pop and to be
fair it sounded ok, the whole range was present and the volume was
about comparable with the Logic3 speakers and the 2 x 6 Watt units
did their best to generate some bass. Changing to a funky number
from the latest Jamiroquai album, the Houseparty started to show the
cracks, bass distortion was present from around 70% of full volume
and even when it doesn't distort it sound pretty unconvincing.
Just to check it wasn't anything to do with the iPod we fed in a
CD player using the Podgear's auxiliary input, we got the same
results with a muddy sounding reproduction of James Brown and a
horrible distorted bass line. Of course we were meant to be
marvelling at the blue LED's that light up your iPod when sat in the
Houseparty's cradle and it's overall styling (which isn't bad) but
we just can't let you buy one of these without telling the truth.
The
120 x 230 x92mm Podgear Houseparty isn't that small and required a
mains adaptor which weighs as much as the whole unit to drive it
making is a less than portable system. Perhaps if we had not used
the Logic3 iStation we'd not have been so hard on the Podgear
offering and accepted that for this kind of money the sound is
unlikely to be 1st class.
The truth however is that you can either spend £50 on a Podgear
Houseparty and get the equivalent of a boy racers keved up fiesta
(all downlighters and no engine) or invest less (around £40) to buy
a better sounding iStation. We know which we'd choose and our
offices are even in Essex.

Published - 01/10/2005
More MP3 Speaker Reviews-
[ Up ] [ Logic3 iStation ] [ TDK Outloud CD wallet with integrated speakers ] [ Creative Travelsound ] [ inMotion iMmini ] [ JBL On Stage ] [ inMotion IM3 Review ] [ Moshi iPouch ] [ Monitor Audio i ] [ Podgear Pocket Party ] [ Podgear Houseparty ] [ TruePower iPod Battery ] [ Zen Micro Traveldock ] [ Logitech MM28 Review ] [ Belkin Tunecast ] [ Griffin iTrip Auto Review ] [ Belkin Tunebase ] [ Logitech Z-10 Speakers ] [ DLO Homedock Deluxe Review ] [ Oregon Scientific iBall Review ] [ iTrip Nano Review ] [ Altec Lansing IM5 Review ] [ iPod Radio Remote ] [ Apple iPod HiFi Review ] [ Intempo IDS-01 Speakers ] [ Inmotion IM4 Speakers ] [ Griffin IFM ] [ inMotion IM7 Review ] [ Bose SoundDock Review ] [ Stripy iPod Speakers ] [ Tivoli iPal ] |