
When we saw our first TomTom we were taken back at its simplicity
and stunned at how it made a once expensive high end in car option
available to anyone with a few hundred pounds. So when we got our
TomTom Go 520 for review we wondered what the gradual evolution
rather than revolution of TomTom could surprise us with?Slide the
520 out of the box and apart from a smaller and slimmer design yet
retaining a good sized screen the 520 looks like a TomTom. The mount
is a slightly revised version of the one on the 510 and 710 and
should hold the unit firmly enough and allows quick removal when you
leave the car. Fire up the 520 and the familiar and yet improved
TomTom UI leaps into life but beneath the friendly and simple
interface lies a new twist to SatNav (at least for TomTom) one that
means our grubby mitts may just stay off the unit and help keep the
screen clean.
The headline grabber here is not just text to speech conversion
so you get spoken road names, but the reverse speech to text so you
can now say your destination to your TomTom and it will lay in the
route, cool eh? So without further delay we leapt into trying out
the new spangly features and you'll have to take our word that as a
navigation device the new 520 is up to the mark of pervious TTG
units.
So the voice control, well the unit shows no obvious signs of
being voice activated no big stickers or flashing lights, just a
menu option to speak your address, it guides you through from city
to street to house number. As you say each section it repeats back
and shows on screen a list of possibilities, you can either say Ok
to select if it has got it right or jump in and use the touch
screen. Our first test was while sat in the office and we managed to
enter a London address first time with the 520 getting the correct
street 1st time. We tried a few tricky names with about a 90%
success rate with only 1 street causing a few issues, you do have to
speak very clearly which concerned us a little for our next test.
As the TomTom is going to be in car we had to test the voice
input while in car with engine running and then on the move, both of
which are very common situations. The first test stationary with
engine running (but radio off) went as well as those in the office,
we then set off at about 30mph and hit the button and attempted to
enter a destination. City was fine but the street accuracy seemed to
drop as background noise started to kick in and the unit struggled
to differentiate between words.
Increase speed further and sadly much like the hands free on
earlier TTG models the voice recognition falls apart to the point
where at motorway speeds we just gave up trying. Although not
entirely unexpected it is a shame as on the move the voice control
could really add an element of safety which will stop people trying
to operate menus while on the move. In truth the voice control is
perfect when sat ready to move off as a lazy mans way to input a
destination.
Now if that was all that's new on this TomTom Go 520 the review
would be fairly short and perhaps struggle to recommend an upgrade,
but the Dutch company have gone further and added more to this new
unit. A very nifty feature is an FM transmitter, these until
recently were illegal in the UK but a change in the law has made
them appear in all sorts of units. The 520 uses FM transmission to
link its audio output to your car stereo meaning you can have the
TomTom spoken instructions very loud and clear! also you can finally
make use of the MP3 player on the Go which had always been a joke
when limited to the units own speaker.
This
520 differs from the more expensive 720 in that it uses internal
flash memory of 215mb and maps are stored on SD / MMC cards which
slide into the unit, the 720 has a hard drive and also has street
level euro maps where as this unit has UK and Eire plus the main
roads of western Europe. If you are planning to stay in blighty this
is all you'll ever need and you can buy more maps for download via
TomTom Home should you need a map for say France only.
One of our reviews around Christmas time was of the TMC extra
that TomTom had started to ship, the Fm receiver was an outboard
unit which uses FM transmission of traffic data to update the screen
of the TomTom. This is now standard on the 520 and 720 and has been
better integrated in this 3rd generation UI, where traffic alerts
pop up and ask you if you want to re router, you can even use the
voice control to say yes or no. from our tests it seems that even
the TMC data has gotten a little better and now that you are not
forking out extra for it, we can recommend it as a nice extra.
Mapping has taken a bit of a leap into the web 2.0 world too with
MapShare, which TomTom claim to be a community based mapping system,
whereby users can amend maps, so if you find something wrong, say a
speed limit or one way street you can make a note on your unit. Then
when you next connect up to a PC running the TomTom home software
your change is uploaded to TomTom who check it and then should
update the maps of everyone else! This makes things like the speed
camera maps and speed safety warning system more reliable and is a
good idea.
We wonder where this ends though? give the TTG a full time data
connection and you could upload your location in real time, if
enough users did this it would form a highly accurate traffic
system, far fetched? maybe not.
Delve a little further and we get into the extras bundle which
this time includes "guides" a series of unit based notes to help
with certain situations which appear under a menu called Help me.
The available guides on the system are based on a text viewer with
embedded hyperlinks and while the idea is a good one with both first
aid and driving guides a few minutes use shows that the screen and
the navigation is not suited to this kind of guide. Try scrolling
down the list of country driving guides to fin the UK and you soon
discover that you cannot keep your finger on the touch screen and
scroll leaving you madly tapping the screen like a loony.
Also under help me section is a quick way to call the emergency
services presuming you have your mobile hooked up to the Go 520 via
Bluetooth, you can call for help and also to the AA or for that
matter any number you programme using the hands free system. The
nice touch is that your current location is displayed on screen in
simple to read notes so you can tell whoever you have called, the
list of help types includes hospitals and even has their phone
numbers.
We haven't neglected the basic navigation capability of the
TomTom 520 in the review, during all these tests the Go performed
way above its competition in route selection, re routing, guidance
and quality of both displayed and spoken instructions. Its hard to
explain other than to say that the TomTom UI is the iPod of SatNav
systems and nothing else comes close. For example we are all used to
being able to download new voices for your SatNav but the 3rd Gen
TomTom goes one step further, you can record your own. Simply speak
the 57 phrases needed into your Go and you can soon be guided by
your own voice, or perhaps that of the Wife! (shivers).
Measuring 118 x 83 x 24mm and weighing 220 grams the new TomTom
Go 520 is smaller than the older series with a much improved
mounting system making it far more portable, it even has an improved
5hr battery to make navigation away from a power source more
practical.
Priced at just under £250 as we went to press the TomTom Go 520
is the most complete system we have tested to date, sure we can pick
little holes in some of the extras but as a rounded SatNav system
you just can't beat the 3rd generation in TomTom's

Published - 01/10/2007
More SatNav Reviews -
[ Up ] [ Navman iCN510 Review ] [ Garmin C320 Review ] [ Mio 268 Review ] [ Magellan Roadmate 300 ] [ TomTom Go 700 ] [ GPS Navigation System Reviews ] [ Mio 269 Review ] [ TomTom One ] [ Mio A201 Review ] [ TomTom Rider Motorbike GPS ] [ Medion GoPal 350 Review ] [ Mio C210 Review ] [ Sony Nav-U Review ] [ Garmin i2 Review ] [ TomTom One Europe Review ] [ Navman N60i Review ] [ TomTom Go 520 Review ] [ Navman N20 Review ] [ Mio GPS Review ] [ Garmin Zumo 550 Review ] [ TomTom One XL ] [ Navman F20 Review ] [ Loox N100 Review ] [ Snooper Indago Review ] [ Acer D100 Review ] [ TomTom Go 910 Review ] [ Garmin i3 Review ] [ Garmin Nuvi Review ] [ Navman iCN320 Review ] [ TomTom Go 500 ] [ TomTom Go 300 Review ] [ Acer N35 Review ] |